Appraisal came in low? What happens next and how to check the facts
By Lysting research13 minute readChecked against its sources on
When an appraisal comes in low, the loan changes, not the contract price. What the contract and the lender's rules allow, and which facts can be checked.
What changes
The loan, not the contract price. On a purchase, Fannie Mae has the lender use the lower of the sales price or the appraised value.
Who can ask for a reconsideration
On Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac loans, the borrower, through the lender, once per appraisal and before closing.
Who gets the report
The loan applicant. The lender owes a copy promptly, or three business days before closing, whichever is earlier.
How often
9.2% of purchase appraisals on conventional loans from 2013 through 2023 were below the contract price, by FHFA's count.
In this guide
What happens
What happens if an appraisal comes in low?
The contract price does not change by itself. The loan does: on a purchase, Fannie Mae has the lender use the lower of the sales price or the appraised value. The gap is then met with cash, a new price or a second look at the appraisal, or the sale fails. The contract and the lender decide which.
"Low" has one meaning here: the appraised value is under the price in the contract. It compares two numbers. It does not say the appraisal is inaccurate, and nothing in this guide says that either.
The number matters because of how a loan is sized. Fannie Mae's Selling Guide divides the loan amount by the property value, and on a purchase, "The property value is the lower of the sales price or the current appraised value."2 A loan that was 90% of the price becomes 90% of something smaller. Other loan programs have their own rule, and the lender can say which applies.
From there a sale goes one of five ways. The buyer and seller agree a new price. The buyer pays the difference in cash. The lender orders a second appraisal. The lender asks the appraiser to reconsider. Or the sale fails.
The first, second and last are between buyer and seller, and the contract governs them. The third and fourth run through the lender, under published rules that most explanations skip.
One thing comes before all of it. The lender owes the loan applicant a copy of the appraisal "promptly upon completion, or three business days prior to consummation of the transaction," whichever is earlier, and may not charge for the copy.3 The regulation gives that right to the applicant. A seller or a listing agent sees the report only if the buyer shares it.
How often
How often do appraisals come in low?
About one purchase appraisal in eleven. The Federal Housing Finance Agency reported in April 2024 that, from 2013 through 2023, 9.2% of purchase appraisals in Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac's data were below the contract price, 25.9% were equal to it and 64.8% were above it. The count covers conventional, conforming loans only.
The Federal Housing Finance Agency (FHFA) oversees Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac and publishes aggregate statistics from the appraisals lenders send them.1 In a post dated April 12, 2024 it gave the split for purchase appraisals from the first quarter of 2013 through the fourth quarter of 2023: 9.2% below the contract price, 25.9% equal to it, 64.8% above.
Two cautions about that figure. The post is no longer on FHFA's site, so we cite the dataset it drew on, which is still published. And the data covers conventional, conforming loans; cash purchases and other loan types are not in it.
It is a national figure over eleven years, and it says nothing about one county this month. FHFA's dashboards break the same data down by state, metropolitan area, county and census tract. We did not read quarters after 2023 for this guide.
Appraisal gap
What is an appraisal gap, with an example?
An appraisal gap is the difference between the contract price and a lower appraised value. In an invented example, a $400,000 price and a $385,000 appraisal leave a $15,000 gap. Appraisal gap coverage is a contract clause in which the buyer agrees to pay some or all of that difference in cash.
The gap and the extra cash are not the same number. Here is the arithmetic for a buyer who planned to borrow 90% of the price, using Fannie Mae's rule that the lender takes the lower of the two values.2
Scroll across for all columns.
| Before the appraisal | After it | |
|---|---|---|
| Value the lender uses | $400,000 | $385,000 |
| Loan at 90% of that value | $360,000 | $346,500 |
| Cash needed to close at $400,000 | $40,000 | $53,500 |
Invented figures. Closing costs are left out, and the 90% is an assumption: the lender sets the share it will lend.
The gap is $15,000. The extra cash is $13,500, because the loan fell by 90% of the gap and the buyer was always bringing the other 10%.
Appraisal gap coverage is what agents call a clause, in the purchase contract or an addendum to it, in which the buyer agrees ahead of time to bring cash for a gap. A clause can cover the whole gap or stop at a stated amount. It is contract language, not a loan feature and not insurance. None of the lender rules cited in this guide defines it, so a given clause covers exactly what it says.
Contingency
What is an appraisal contingency?
An appraisal contingency is a clause in a purchase contract that says what happens if the property appraises below the contract price. Its wording differs from one state's form to the next, and the parties can change or strike it. It is separate from a financing contingency, and a contract can have one, both or neither.
Four contract terms carry most of what follows a low appraisal. None of them comes from a lender's rulebook.
- Appraisal contingency
- Says what the buyer, the seller or both may do if the appraised value is below the contract price.
- Financing contingency
- Tied to the buyer getting the loan. A lower appraised value can change the loan without the contract mentioning appraisals at all.
- Appraisal gap coverage
- The buyer's agreement to pay some or all of a gap in cash.
- Earnest money
- The buyer's deposit, held until closing. The contract says when it goes back to the buyer and when it is forfeited.
A clause of this kind has three working parts: what sets it off, how many days a party has to act, and what each side may do then. Those are the three things to find in your own contract. A general description of contingencies, this one included, cannot tell you what yours says.
Earnest money
Do you lose your earnest money if the appraisal is low?
It depends on the contract, with one exception in federal rules. VA will not guarantee a loan on a contract signed before the veteran learned VA's value unless the contract says the buyer forfeits no earnest money when the price exceeds that value. On other loans, the contract's contingencies and deadlines decide.
The VA rule is in 38 CFR 36.4303(k). It applies when the price is above the "reasonable value" VA establishes and the veteran signed before receiving notice of that value. The contract then has to include a provision that reads substantially as follows:4
It is expressly agreed that, notwithstanding any other provisions of this contract, the purchaser shall not incur any penalty by forfeiture of earnest money or otherwise be obligated to complete the purchase of the property described herein, if the contract purchase price or cost exceeds the reasonable value of the property established by the Department of Veterans Affairs.
The same provision keeps the door open the other way: the purchaser has "the privilege and option of proceeding" whatever the VA's value is.
For a conventional loan there is no such sentence in the lender rules cited here. The deposit follows the contract: whether there is an appraisal or financing contingency, whether it was waived, and whether notice was given inside the days the contract allows.
The seller's side
Can a seller walk away if an appraisal is low?
Only if the contract gives the seller that right. The lender rules cited in this guide govern the loan, not the sale: none gives a seller a right to cancel over an appraised value, and none makes a seller lower the price. What each side may do, and by when, is in the contract.
When a low appraisal meets a seller who won't budge on price, the published rules give neither side a lever on the other. The appraisal limits what the lender will lend. It does not reprice the contract.
The seller also stands outside the lender's process. The seller has no right to the report under Regulation B3 and cannot start a reconsideration of value, which Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac make the borrower's to request.5 What the rules leave open to a seller's side is narrower: Fannie Mae's independence requirements let "any party" ask the appraiser "to correct factual errors in an appraisal report."6
Reconsideration of value
What is a reconsideration of value, and who can ask for one?
A reconsideration of value (ROV) is a request, sent through the lender, for the appraiser to look again at the report. On Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac loans only the borrower can start one, once per appraisal and before closing, with up to five alternative comparables. The appraiser decides whether anything in the report changes.
"Appraisal dispute," "appraisal rebuttal" and "appraisal appeal" are everyday names for the same thing. The guides use one term. Fannie Mae requires every lender to "have policies and procedures in place for a borrower-initiated reconsideration of value," for use when the borrower believes the opinion of value "is unsupported, may be deficient due to unacceptable appraisal practices, or reflects prohibited discriminatory practices."5 The rule has applied to loans with applications dated on or after October 31, 2024.7 Freddie Mac's Guide section 5604.4 sets the same requirements.8
The lender has to give the borrower a disclosure of the process when it hands over the appraisal, so the instructions for asking arrive with the report.
Scroll across for all columns.
| The request | Who can make it | The rule |
|---|---|---|
| A reconsideration of value | The borrower, through the lender | One per appraisal. None after the loan closes. The lender finishes its own review first. Fannie Mae B4-1.3-12; Freddie Mac 5604.4(b). |
| A correction of "factual errors," or more explanation | Any party, real estate agents included | Fannie Mae bars agents from "substantive communications" with the appraiser about value, then lets any party ask for "additional information or explanation" or "to correct factual errors."6 Regulation Z lists asking an appraiser "to correct errors in the valuation" among the actions that do not breach its independence rule.9 |
| The lender's own review | The lender | The lender may go back to the appraiser, order a desk or field review, or order a new appraisal. A request to change the value "must not be made solely on the basis that" it "does not support the proposed loan amount." B4-1.3-12. |
| A copy of the appraisal | The loan applicant | Regulation B, 12 CFR 1002.14(a)(1).3 |
Two things follow for agents. An agent cannot file the ROV: it is the borrower's request and it goes to the lender. And Regulation Z, which counts real estate agents among its "covered persons," gives as an example of a violation "Seeking to influence a person that prepares a valuation to report a minimum or maximum value."9 Pointing to a fact is allowed. Asking for a number is not.
What a borrower's request contains
We found no Fannie Mae or Freddie Mac form for this. Each lender writes its own, carrying these items:
The identifying details
The borrower's name, the property address, the effective date of the appraisal, the appraiser's name and the date of the request.The parts of the report in question
Fannie Mae's words are "Identification and description of unsupported, inaccurate, or deficient areas in the appraisal report." Those are the borrower's words to write. A comparison of documents can show that two records differ. It cannot call a report deficient.New data, with its source
"Additional data, information, or comparable properties (not to exceed five), and the related data sources (for example, the MLS listing number)." The borrower or the borrower's agent chooses the comparables. Lysting does not.
The lender checks that the request has enough detail and sends it on. The appraiser answers in a revised report "that includes commentary on conclusions regardless of the outcome." Neither guide sets a number of days. Each lender defines its own "turn-time expectations" and can tell you what they are.
The four loan programs today
Scroll across for all columns.
| Program | Can the borrower start one? | The rule as it stands |
|---|---|---|
| Fannie Mae | Yes | Selling Guide B4-1.3-12, dated September 3, 2025. One per appraisal, up to five comparables, none after closing. |
| Freddie Mac | Yes | Guide 5604.4(b), dated September 3, 2025. The same limits. Where state law requires more, "the State law or regulation controls." |
| FHA | Not today | Mortgagee Letter 2025-08 of March 19, 2025 rescinded the borrower-initiated process FHA had announced on May 1, 2024. The restored text: "The underwriter may request a reconsideration of value when the Appraiser did not consider information that was relevant on the effective date of the appraisal."10 |
| VA | Yes, to VA | After a Notice of Value is issued, "the Veteran may request a reconsideration of value," and VA staff review it within "5 business days."11 |
The VA row is from a VA bulletin of December 16, 2021. The Lenders Handbook chapter it points to was not read for this guide.
Banks, credit unions and other federally supervised lenders also have guidance, which is not a rule. The interagency guidance of July 26, 2024 describes how a lender may run an ROV process and says of itself that it "does not have the force and effect of law or regulation."12
Congress has since stepped in. Section 704 of the 21st Century ROAD to Housing Act, which became law on July 11, 2026, tells the Department of Agriculture, VA, FHA and FHFA to "implement and maintain requirements that creditors of a federally backed mortgage loan have a review and resolution procedure for a consumer-initiated reconsideration of value or subsequent appraisal."13 We found no agency rule issued under it, FHA's included.
The reconsideration rules, by date
- May 1, 2024Borrower-initiated ROV announcedFannie Mae's Announcement SEL-2024-03 and FHA's Mortgagee Letter 2024-07.
- Jul 26, 2024Interagency guidance is final89 FR 60549, from the banking agencies, the NCUA and the CFPB. Guidance, not a rule.
- Aug 6, 2024The start date moves by 60 daysFannie Mae, "in coordination with Freddie Mac and HUD."
- Oct 31, 2024The rule takes effectFor loans with applications dated on or after this day.
- Mar 19, 2025FHA rescinds its versionMortgagee Letter 2025-08, effective immediately.
- Sep 3, 2025Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac reissue their textB4-1.3-12 and Guide 5604.4 as they read today. The disclosure comes with the appraisal report.
- Jul 11, 2026The ROAD to Housing Act becomes lawSection 704 directs four agencies to require a consumer-initiated process. No agency rule found yet.
RelatedReconsideration of value: who can ask and what the request holds
Tidewater
What does Tidewater mean on a VA appraisal?
Tidewater is VA's name for a notice given before a purchase appraisal is finished. If it appears the value will be below the sales price, the appraiser tells the party that requested the appraisal and allows 2 business days for additional sales data. VA first piloted it in the Tidewater area of Virginia.
What agents call a Tidewater appraisal is an ordinary VA appraisal that has reached this step. VA described the step in a bulletin on December 16, 2021:
Before an appraisal is completed for a purchase transaction, the appraiser will notify the requester if it appears that the estimated market value will be below the sales price. The appraiser will allow 2 business days for the requester, or parties to the transaction contacted by the requester, to submit any additional sales data that they wish to have considered.
It differs from a reconsideration of value in its timing. Tidewater comes before the report is complete and asks for sales data only. VA's reconsideration comes after the Notice of Value, and it is the veteran who asks. The bulletin places the detail in chapter 10 of the VA Lenders Handbook, topics 8 and 22, which we did not read for this guide.
Facts to check
What facts in an appraisal can be checked?
The recorded ones: the address and legal description, finished area, bedroom and bathroom counts, lot size, zoning, flood zone, and each comparable's sale date and price. Each can be set beside the county property record, a recorded deed or the listing. Which record is right is the appraiser's to determine.
An appraisal report holds two kinds of statement. Some are records: the address, the site's size, the room count. The rest are judgment: the value, the choice of comparables, the adjustments between them, the condition and quality ratings. On comparables, Fannie Mae is plain about whose call it is: "The appraiser is responsible for determining which comparables are the best and most appropriate for the assignment."14
This guide stays with the first kind. Florida law reserves to licensed appraisers any "analysis, opinion, or conclusion relating to the nature, quality, value, or utility" of real property, and it defines an appraisal review as "an opinion about the quality of another appraiser's appraisal, appraisal report, or work."15 So this guide, like a Lysting report, sets one record beside another and stops there.
An example of two records that differ
AppraisalImprovements
3 bedrooms. Finished area above grade: 1,640 sq ft
County property recordBuilding
4 bedrooms. Living area: 1,812 sq ft
Facts to set beside the public record
- Address and legal description, against the deed and the county parcel record.
- Finished area above grade, and any below-grade area reported separately, against the county's building record and the listing sheet.
- Bedroom and bathroom counts, against the same two.
- Site size, against the parcel record or a survey.
- Zoning class, against the local zoning map.
- Flood zone, map number and map date, against FEMA's flood map.
- Whether the home was offered for sale in the 12 months before the appraisal's effective date, against the listing history.
- Contract price and contract date, against the signed contract.
- Each comparable's address, sale date and sale price, against the data source the report names for it, such as deed or tax records.
- Additions, against the building department's permit record. The guide to Florida seller disclosure covers where Florida keeps those records.
The Selling Guide's sections on the subject, the site, the improvements and the sales comparison say what a report has to state on each of these.14 The second step of a borrower's request is where a borrower can point to a difference, with the page of the report and the public record beside it.
The dates of the change from the old appraisal form to the redesigned report, through June 2027, are set out in Florida condo and mortgage deadlines for 2026 and 2027.
More questions
- Can the seller or the listing agent get a copy of the appraisal?
- Not from the lender. Regulation B gives the right to a copy to the loan applicant, who is the buyer. A seller or listing agent sees the report only if the buyer chooses to share it.
- Can a real estate agent file a reconsideration of value?
- Not on a Fannie Mae or Freddie Mac loan. The request is the borrower's and goes through the lender. An agent can supply comparables and their sources for the borrower's request, and under Fannie Mae's independence requirements any party may ask the appraiser "to correct factual errors."
- Does FHA have a borrower-initiated reconsideration of value?
- Not at present. FHA announced one on May 1, 2024 and rescinded it in Mortgagee Letter 2025-08 on March 19, 2025. Under the restored handbook text the underwriter may request a reconsideration. A law of July 11, 2026 directs FHA to require a consumer-initiated process, and we found no FHA rule under it.
- Can you ask for a reconsideration of value after closing?
- No. Fannie Mae's Selling Guide says that after a loan has closed, an ROV request is no longer allowed, and Freddie Mac's Guide says the same. Each appraisal also gets only one borrower-initiated request.
- How many comparables can a reconsideration of value include?
- Up to five. Fannie Mae's wording is "not to exceed five" and Freddie Mac's is a "maximum of five alternative comparables," each with its data source, such as the MLS listing number.
- What does the lender have to tell a borrower about a reconsideration of value?
- On Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac loans the lender gives the borrower a disclosure outlining the reconsideration of value process when it delivers the appraisal report (Fannie Mae Selling Guide B4-1.3-12; Freddie Mac Guide 5604.4). Fannie Mae's text says the disclosure has to make clear that only one borrower-initiated request is permitted per appraisal, and Freddie Mac's says it has to include instructions for making the request. Fannie Mae's 2024 announcement asked for it at loan application as well, and Freddie Mac's bulletin of September 3, 2025 ended its own dual disclosure, so both texts now ask for it once, with the appraisal.
- Can Lysting tell me whether the appraisal is wrong?
- No. An opinion on the quality of an appraiser's work is an appraisal review, which Florida reserves to licensed appraisers. The Lysting appraisal check is planned to set what the report records beside the county record and the listing sheet, and to leave what a difference means to the appraiser and the lender.
Sources
Every rule, date and limit above comes from one of these. The examples marked invented use invented figures. Where a rule is quoted, the wording is the source's.
- 1Uniform Appraisal Dataset (UAD) Aggregate StatisticsFederal Housing Finance Agency
- 2Selling Guide B2-1.2-01, Loan-to-Value (LTV) RatiosFannie Mae, Guide of November 4, 2026
- 3Regulation B, 12 CFR 1002.14, Rules on providing appraisals and other valuationsConsumer Financial Protection Bureau
- 438 CFR 36.4303(k), Reporting requirementsDepartment of Veterans Affairs, via eCFR
- 5Selling Guide B4-1.3-12, Appraisal Quality MattersFannie Mae, Dated September 3, 2025; Guide of November 4, 2026
- 6Appraiser Independence RequirementsFannie Mae
- 7Selling Notice, Updated Implementation Date to Oct. 31st for Reconsideration of ValueFannie Mae, August 6, 2024
- 8Seller/Servicer Guide 5604.4, Reviewing appraisal reports, reconsideration of value requested by the BorrowerFreddie Mac, Effective September 3, 2025
- 9Regulation Z, 12 CFR 1026.42, Valuation independence, with official interpretationConsumer Financial Protection Bureau
- 10Mortgagee Letter 2025-08, Rescinding Multiple Appraisal Policy Related Mortgagee LettersU.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development, March 19, 2025
- 11VA Appraisal PoliciesVeterans Benefits Administration, Loan Guaranty Service, December 16, 2021
- 12Interagency Guidance on Reconsiderations of Value of Residential Real Estate Valuations, 89 FR 60549OCC, Federal Reserve Board, FDIC, NCUA and CFPB, July 26, 2024
- 1321st Century ROAD to Housing Act, Pub. L. 119-101, s. 704(a)U.S. Congress, via GovInfo, July 11, 2026
- 14Selling Guide Section B4-1.3, Appraisal Report Assessment (B4-1.3-02, B4-1.3-04, B4-1.3-07, B4-1.3-08)Fannie Mae, Guide of November 4, 2026
- 15Florida Statutes s. 475.611(1)(e) and (f), definitions of appraisal report and appraisal reviewFlorida Legislature, 2026 Statutes
- 16Selling Guide B4-1.3-05, Improvements Section of the Appraisal ReportFannie Mae, Dated June 4, 2025; Guide of November 4, 2026
This guide states what the published rules and forms say. It is not legal, lending, insurance, engineering or valuation advice, and it does not decide anything about a particular property. Rules change; read the source, and ask the person named in each section.