Reconsideration of value: who can ask, what the request holds and how it is decided
By Lysting research12 minute readChecked against its sources on
A reconsideration of value asks the appraiser, through the lender, to look at an appraisal again. Who may ask on each loan type, what it holds and who decides.
Who files
On loans sold to Fannie Mae or Freddie Mac, the borrower, through the lender. An agent or a seller cannot.
The limits
One request per appraisal, up to five comparable properties, and none once the loan has closed.
FHA loans
No borrower-initiated process since March 19, 2025. The underwriter may request a reconsideration.
Who decides
The lender decides whether a request goes to the appraiser. The appraiser decides whether the report changes.
In this guide
What it is
What is a reconsideration of value?
A reconsideration of value (ROV) is a request, sent through the lender, for the appraiser to reassess an appraisal report. On loans sold to Fannie Mae or Freddie Mac a borrower can start one when the opinion of value seems unsupported, deficient or discriminatory. The appraiser decides whether the report changes.
The regulator of Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac defined it on the day the two companies published their rules:
A Reconsideration of Value is a request to an appraiser to re-assess the appraised value of a property due to potential appraisal reporting deficiencies or inappropriate selection of comparable properties, or based upon additional information the appraiser should consider.
Fannie Mae's Selling Guide gives a borrower three grounds. The lender's process has to include steps to appeal an appraisal when the borrower believes the opinion of value2
- "is unsupported,"
- "may be deficient due to unacceptable appraisal practices," or
- "reflects prohibited discriminatory practices."
"Unacceptable appraisal practices" is a defined list in the Guide. Its examples include "misrepresentation of the physical characteristics of the subject property, improvements, or comparable sales" and "selection and use of inappropriate comparable sales."3
The borrower's request also sits beside the lender's own. Fannie Mae says its rules "do not replace the lender's underwriting practices, which may provide for an ROV to be requested by someone other than the borrower."4
RelatedWhat a value below the contract price does to the loan, the contract and the earnest money
Who can ask
Who can request a reconsideration of value?
On a loan sold to Fannie Mae or Freddie Mac, the borrower asks, through the lender, once per appraisal and before closing. On an FHA loan the underwriter may ask and the borrower has no process of their own. VA runs a separate process. Other lenders set their own policies under federal guidance.
The answer depends on who will own or insure the loan, so the first question for a lender is which program the loan is written under.
Scroll across for all columns.
| Loan | Who can start it | Limits in the text | Where it is written |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fannie Mae | The borrower, through the lender. The lender's own underwriting may provide for others. | One per appraisal. Comparable properties "not to exceed five." None after the loan has closed. | Selling Guide B4-1.3-12, dated September 3, 20252 |
| Freddie Mac | The borrower, through the lender, which the Guide calls the Seller. | One per appraisal. A "maximum of five alternative comparables." None once a loan is closed. | Guide 5604.4(b), effective September 3, 20255 |
| FHA | The underwriter. | "When the Appraiser did not consider information that was relevant on the effective date of the appraisal." No borrower-initiated process. | Handbook 4000.1, II.A.3.a.ix, as restored by Mortgagee Letter 2025-086 |
| VA | Set by VA. | Not in the rules this guide quotes. | VA Lenders Handbook, which this guide's sources do not include. |
| A lender's own loan | Whatever the lender's policy provides. | None fixed. The guidance describes policies a lender "may consider." | Interagency guidance, 89 FR 60549, July 26, 20247 |
The Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac rows apply to loans that require an appraisal report.
The two conventional rules started together. Fannie Mae announced its version on May 1, 2024 for applications dated on or after August 29, then, "in coordination with Freddie Mac and HUD," moved the date by 60 days. Lenders have had to follow it for loans with applications dated on or after October 31, 2024.8
Freddie Mac adds one sentence Fannie Mae's section does not have: its requirements "are minimum standards. If State law or regulation requires more than Freddie Mac's guidelines, the State law or regulation controls."5
Nobody else in the sale is named. A seller, a listing agent and a buyer's agent have no request of their own under either guide. What an agent may do is a separate question, answered further down.
What the request holds
What does a reconsideration of value request have to include?
Fannie Mae requires four things: the borrower's name, the property address, the appraisal's effective date, the appraiser's name and the request date; the areas of the report in question; additional data or up to five comparable properties with their sources; and an explanation of why the new data supports the request. The lender supplies the form.
Freddie Mac asks for the same four in slightly different words. Side by side:
Scroll across for all columns.
| Item | Fannie Mae, B4-1.3-12 | Freddie Mac, 5604.4(b) |
|---|---|---|
| Identification | "Borrower(s) name, Property address, Effective date of the appraisal, Appraiser name, and Date of the ROV request." | "the Borrower(s) name, property address and the effective date of the appraisal, appraiser's name and date of the ROV submission" |
| The parts of the report in question | "Identification and description of unsupported, inaccurate, or deficient areas in the appraisal report." | "Identifying specific issues and deficiencies in the appraisal report" |
| New information | "Additional data, information, or comparable properties (not to exceed five), and the related data sources (for example, the MLS listing number)." | "detailed information, data or alternative comparable properties (maximum of five alternative comparables are permitted), including the source of the data" |
| The reason | "An explanation of why the new data supports the ROV." | "the rationale for the inclusion of the alternative comparables, information or data" |
There is no agency form. Asked whether it would provide one, Fannie Mae answered: "No, lenders are responsible for creating and providing forms that include the information required by the Fannie Mae Selling Guide."4 So the layout differs from lender to lender and the four items do not.
Five is a ceiling on comparable properties. Neither guide sets a minimum, and neither says which sales count.
Whatever the borrower sends, the appraiser checks. Fannie Mae counts as an unacceptable practice the "use of data, particularly comparable sales data, provided by parties that have a financial interest in the sale or in the financing of the subject property without the appraiser's verification of the information from a disinterested source."3 That is why both guides ask for the data source with every comparable.
What a request draws on
- The appraisal report, for its effective date and the appraiser's name.
- The lender's disclosure of the process, which arrives with the report and carries the instructions.
- The lender's own form, since neither Fannie Mae nor Freddie Mac publishes one.
- The pages of the report the request refers to.
- Each added comparable, five at most, with its data source, such as the MLS listing number.
- The source of any other data, which Freddie Mac describes as a "multiple listing service listing or publicly available information."
The lender's steps
What does the lender do with a reconsideration of value request?
The lender finishes its own review of the appraisal first, has an underwriter or appraisal specialist check that the borrower's request has enough detail, and sends it to the appraiser in a standard format. The appraiser answers in a revised report with commentary, whatever the outcome. The lender decides what it relies on.
Both guides set the same sequence. The words quoted are Fannie Mae's unless marked.2
The lender completes its own review
It has to "complete its appraisal review before initiating the ROV process." A borrower's request does not jump that queue.A named reviewer reads the request
The lender designates "an underwriter or other appraisal subject matter expert to review the ROV request."The lender checks the detail
It validates that the request "contains sufficient details prior to sending to the appraiser" and goes back to the borrower "if the ROV request is unclear or needs more information." Freddie Mac's test is "sufficient detail to warrant reengagement of the appraiser."5The request goes to the appraiser in a standard format
The same identification, the described areas of the report, the added data with no more than five comparables, the turn time the lender expects, and instructions for the response.The appraiser responds in a revised report
The response comes "as part of a revised appraisal report that includes commentary on conclusions regardless of the outcome." Where the request points to a minor error that does not affect value, Fannie Mae still has the appraiser "update the appraisal report to correct any errors and provide comments on the change(s)."4The lender reports back and keeps the record
Freddie Mac requires lenders to define "turn-time expectations for communicating results of the ROV to the Borrower." Documentation "related to the outcome of the ROV is retained in the loan file."
If the value does not change, the borrower has no second step. Asked whether the borrower may then request a new appraisal, Fannie Mae answered: "No, the decision whether to accept the appraiser's conclusions is the responsibility of the lender."4 The lender's own options are in the same Selling Guide topic: go back to the appraiser, order a desk or field review, or order a new appraisal, in which case it has to "adhere to a policy of selecting the most reliable appraisal, rather than the appraisal that states the highest value."2
Two more things can happen. A borrower can withdraw: "the borrower may cancel a borrower-initiated ROV request."4 And where material deficiencies "are not corrected or addressed by the appraiser upon request," the lender has to send the report and a summary of findings to "the appropriate appraisal licensing agency or regulatory board."2
How long it takes
How long does a reconsideration of value take?
Neither Fannie Mae nor Freddie Mac sets a number of days. Each lender has to define its own turn-time expectations for the appraiser's response and for telling the borrower the result. The one fixed limit is the closing: once the loan has closed, a borrower's request is no longer allowed.
So the working window opens when the borrower receives the appraisal and shuts at closing. Regulation B sets when the copy arrives: "promptly upon completion, or three business days prior to consummation of the transaction," whichever is earlier.10 The same rule lets an applicant waive that timing and take the copy at closing, which can leave little or no time before the loan closes.
The instructions come with the report. Fannie Mae's 2024 announcement had lenders give the disclosure twice, at application and again with the appraisal.11 The text dated September 3, 2025 asks for it once, "when the appraisal report is provided to the borrower," and it has to "make it clear that only one borrower-initiated ROV is permitted per appraisal."2 Freddie Mac's Guide of the same date reads the same way.5
Is a borrower's request still open?
Has the loan closed?
- Yes
- A request is no longer allowed.
- No
- Go on.
Has the borrower already made a request on this appraisal?
- Yes
- Each appraisal gets one borrower-initiated request.
- No
- Go on.
Has the lender delivered the appraisal with its disclosure?
- Yes
- The disclosure carries the lender's instructions and its form.
- No
- The lender owes the copy promptly on completion, or three business days before closing if that is earlier.
Nothing in either guide moves a date in the purchase contract. Whether a financing deadline, an appraisal contingency or an appraisal gap clause leaves room for a request is set by the contract, not by the lender's process.
What an agent may do
What can a real estate agent do in a reconsideration of value?
An agent cannot file the request: it is the borrower's and goes through the lender. Regulation Z bars agents, as settlement service providers, from trying to influence the value an appraiser reports. It lists as permitted asking the appraiser to consider additional property information, to explain a conclusion, or to correct errors.
The federal rule is 12 CFR 1026.42. It applies to loans secured by the consumer's principal dwelling, and its official commentary names "real estate agents" among the covered persons.12 Fannie Mae has a second, narrower rule of its own for the loans it buys.13
Scroll across for all columns.
| The rule | Its words | Where |
|---|---|---|
| The ban | No covered person may cause the value "to be based on any factor other than the independent judgment of a person that prepares valuations, through coercion, extortion, inducement, bribery, or intimidation." | 1026.42(c)(1) |
| An example of a violation | "Seeking to influence a person that prepares a valuation to report a minimum or maximum value." | 1026.42(c)(1)(i)(A) |
| Permitted: more information | "Asking a person that prepares a valuation to consider additional, appropriate property information, including information about comparable properties." | 1026.42(c)(3)(i) |
| Permitted: an explanation | Requesting "further detail, substantiation, or explanation for the person's conclusion about the value." | 1026.42(c)(3)(ii) |
| Permitted: a correction | "Asking a person that prepares a valuation to correct errors in the valuation." | 1026.42(c)(3)(iii) |
| Fannie Mae's bar on agents | Restricted parties, who include "real estate agents," may not have "any substantive communications with an appraiser or appraisal management company relating to or having an impact on valuation." | Appraiser Independence Requirements |
| Fannie Mae's exception | Even so, "any party, including any Restricted Party, may request" an appraiser "to provide additional information or explanation about the basis for a valuation, or to correct factual errors in an appraisal report." | Appraiser Independence Requirements |
The commentary explains why the permitted requests are permitted: asking an appraiser to consider more information "does not supplant the independent judgment of the person that prepares a valuation."12 The line falls between pointing to a fact, such as a recorded sale or a gross living area in the county record, and asking for a number.
Inside a borrower's request, the agent's part is the data. Both guides want each comparable's source, and "the MLS listing number" is Fannie Mae's own example. The request still has to keep within the independence rules: "all appraisals and ROVs submitted to Fannie Mae must comply with AIR."4
One Florida limit applies to what an agent calls that data. A broker or sales associate may prepare "a comparative market analysis" or give "a price opinion," but it may not "be referred to or construed as an appraisal."14
A listing agent often works without the report. The lender owes the copy to the loan applicant, and the guide on how to read an appraisal report covers who else can see it.
FHA and VA loans
Is there a reconsideration of value on FHA and VA loans?
FHA has no borrower-initiated process today. It announced one on May 1, 2024 and rescinded it on March 19, 2025, restoring handbook text under which the underwriter may request a reconsideration. VA runs its own process for its loans. A 2026 law directs both agencies to require a consumer-initiated procedure.
FHA's version lasted less than a year. Mortgagee Letter 2024-07 added a borrower-initiated process with the same two limits as the conventional rules: "up to five alternative comparable sales" and "only one borrower-initiated ROV request" per appraisal.15 A second letter tied it to FHA case numbers assigned on or after October 31, 2024.16
Mortgagee Letter 2025-08 rescinded both, "effective immediately." Its stated reasons were "concerns around the cost burden" of the policy and too little data: FHA had begun tracking borrower requests in October 2024, and "there is insufficient data to conduct meaningful analysis."6 The handbook text it restored reads:
The underwriter may request a reconsideration of value when the Appraiser did not consider information that was relevant on the effective date of the appraisal. The underwriter must provide the Appraiser with all relevant data that is necessary for a reconsideration of value.
Three details in the restored text matter to a borrower. The effective date "is the date the Appraiser inspected the Property." The appraiser "may charge an additional fee if the relevant data was not available" on that date, and if that was not the borrower's fault, "the Borrower must not be held responsible for the additional costs." And a second appraisal may be ordered only if the underwriter finds the first "materially deficient and the Appraiser is unable or uncooperative in resolving the deficiency."6
VA loans follow VA's own procedure, including the process known as Tidewater. None of the rules quoted in this guide sets it, and the handbook chapter that holds it is not among this guide's sources. The guide to what happens when an appraisal comes in low quotes VA's own bulletin on what a Tidewater notice is.
Other lenders
Does a bank or credit union have to offer a reconsideration of value?
The banking agencies do not require one. Their guidance of July 26, 2024, from the OCC, the Federal Reserve, the FDIC, the NCUA and the CFPB, describes reconsideration policies a lender may adopt and says it does not have the force and effect of law. A loan sold to Fannie Mae or Freddie Mac still follows their rules.
The guidance covers loans secured by a single 1-to-4 family residential property. It treats a borrower's concern as something that can reach the lender as a complaint or as a request "to the loan officer or other lender representative," and it lists examples of what a lender's policy might do.7 Among them:
- Tell consumers how to raise concerns "early enough in the underwriting process for any errors or issues to be resolved before a final credit decision is made."
- "Establish timelines in the complaint or ROV processes for when milestones need to be achieved."
- "Establish guidelines for when a second appraisal could be ordered and who assumes the cost."
- Consider whether its requirements "create unreasonable barriers or discourage consumers from requesting" a reconsideration.
The agencies call these examples "illustrative and not requirements." One sentence in the guidance does restate a binding rule from the agencies' appraisal regulations: if an appraisal falls short of their minimum standards and "the deficiencies remain uncorrected, the appraisal cannot be used as part of the credit decision."7
The 2026 law
What does the 2026 ROAD to Housing Act require?
Section 704(a) of the 21st Century ROAD to Housing Act, law since July 11, 2026, directs the Department of Agriculture, VA, FHA and FHFA to require that creditors on federally backed mortgage loans keep a review and resolution procedure for a consumer-initiated reconsideration of value. No agency rule under it had been found by November 2026.
The Secretary of Agriculture, the Secretary of Veterans Affairs, the Commissioner of the Federal Housing Administration, and the Director of the Federal Housing Finance Agency shall each implement and maintain requirements that creditors of a federally backed mortgage loan have a review and resolution procedure for a consumer-initiated reconsideration of value or subsequent appraisal in connection with a consumer credit transaction secured by a consumer's principal dwelling.
Set that beside the table above. Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, which FHFA regulates, already require a borrower's process. FHA withdrew its version in March 2025 and is now told to have one. VA and the Department of Agriculture are named as well.
The paragraph itself sets no date and does not say what a procedure has to contain: how many requests, how many comparables, how many days. Those are left to each agency's rule. The same section also orders a report to Congress, within 240 days of enactment, on whether a public database of appraisal data is feasible.17
More questions
- Is a reconsideration of value the same as an appraisal appeal?
- In Fannie Mae's wording, yes. Its Selling Guide describes the reconsideration of value as the steps for a borrower "to appeal an appraisal." Neither its section nor Freddie Mac's uses the words rebuttal or dispute.
- Does a reconsideration of value cost the borrower anything?
- Fannie Mae's and Freddie Mac's sections on the request name no fee. FHA's handbook lets the appraiser charge an additional fee when the relevant data was not available on the effective date of the appraisal, and says the borrower is not to be held responsible for it when that was not the borrower's fault. The lender can say what it charges.
- Can a borrower cancel a reconsideration of value request?
- On a Fannie Mae loan, yes. Fannie Mae's published answer is that the borrower may cancel a borrower-initiated request, and that the lender communicates the cancellation process to the borrower.
- Can the borrower ask for a new appraisal if the value does not change?
- Not under Fannie Mae's rules. Its published answer is that the decision whether to accept the appraiser's conclusions is the lender's. Fannie Mae's independence requirements limit when a lender may order a subsequent appraisal.
- Does a reconsideration of value apply to a refinance?
- Yes. Fannie Mae's requirement covers "loans requiring an appraisal report" and Freddie Mac's covers mortgages "requiring delivery with an appraisal report." Neither is limited to purchases.
- Can Lysting write a reconsideration of value request?
- No. The request is the borrower's, and it goes through the lender. The Lysting appraisal check sets the facts the appraisal records beside other records, cited to the page. It does not say an appraisal is wrong, and it does not choose comparables.
Sources
Every rule, date and limit above comes from one of these. The examples marked invented use invented figures. Where a rule is quoted, the wording is the source's.
- 1FHFA Announces Enterprise Reconsideration of Value PoliciesFederal Housing Finance Agency, May 1, 2024
- 2Selling Guide B4-1.3-12, Appraisal Quality MattersFannie Mae, Dated September 3, 2025; Guide of November 4, 2026
- 3Selling Guide B4-1.1-04, Unacceptable Appraisal PracticesFannie Mae, Dated June 4, 2025; Guide of November 4, 2026
- 4Reconsideration of Value (ROV), with frequently asked questionsFannie Mae, September 3, 2025
- 5Seller/Servicer Guide 5604.4, Reviewing appraisal reports, reconsideration of value requested by the BorrowerFreddie Mac, Effective September 3, 2025
- 6Mortgagee Letter 2025-08, Rescinding Multiple Appraisal Policy Related Mortgagee LettersU.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development, March 19, 2025
- 7Interagency Guidance on Reconsiderations of Value of Residential Real Estate Valuations, 89 FR 60549OCC, Federal Reserve Board, FDIC, NCUA and CFPB, July 26, 2024
- 8Selling Notice, Updated Implementation Date to Oct. 31st for Reconsideration of ValueFannie Mae, August 6, 2024
- 9Florida Statutes s. 475.611(1)(f), definition of appraisal reviewFlorida Legislature, 2026 Statutes
- 10Regulation B, 12 CFR 1002.14, Rules on providing appraisals and other valuationsConsumer Financial Protection Bureau
- 11Selling Guide Announcement SEL-2024-03Fannie Mae, May 1, 2024
- 12Regulation Z, 12 CFR 1026.42, Valuation independence, with official interpretationConsumer Financial Protection Bureau
- 13Appraiser Independence RequirementsFannie Mae
- 14Florida Statutes s. 475.612(3), certification, licensure or registration requiredFlorida Legislature, 2026 Statutes
- 15Mortgagee Letter 2024-07, Appraisal Review and Reconsideration of Value UpdatesU.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development, May 1, 2024; rescinded March 19, 2025
- 16Mortgagee Letter 2024-16, Extension to the Effective Date of Appraisal Review and Reconsideration of Value (ROV) UpdatesU.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development, August 6, 2024; rescinded March 19, 2025
- 1721st Century ROAD to Housing Act, Pub. L. 119-101, s. 704U.S. Congress, via GovInfo, July 11, 2026
This guide states what the published rules and forms say. It is not legal, lending, insurance, engineering or valuation advice, and it does not decide anything about a particular property. Rules change; read the source, and ask the person named in each section.