Appraisal check See where the appraisal and property records disagree on square footage or room counts.
When an appraisal comes in below the contract price, check the measurements, features and room counts against the listing and county records.
Price
For
When
How to order
What the report reads
Start with the appraisal the buyer received from the lender. Add the listing, the county property record and any comparable sales you want to supply.
- The appraisal report
- The listing sheet
- The county property record
- The comparables the agent supplies
What the report checks
- Living area, room counts and features where the appraisal and another record say different things
- An evidence packet for a reconsideration of value request: the records side by side, cited to the page, with the comparables you supplied
Each check has one of these results.MatchesDoesn't matchNot foundNot checked
What the report shows
See how the appraisal and county record describe the same property. The appraiser determines its value. This sample covers 21 checks across 67 pages from 6 documents. Coral Gardens is an invented building.
Coral Gardens · Unit 3B · Appraisal checkSample
- Matches
- 18
- Doesn't match
- 2
- Not found
- 0
- Not checked
- 1
The unit's factsDoesn't match
Living area differs from the county record
Appraisal, Form 1073p.2
Gross living area: 1,180 sq ft
Palm Beach County recordp.1
Living area: 1,342 sq ft
Ask the buyer's lender whether the appraiser has seen the county record.
Document review only. Not legal, financial, engineering or lending advice.
Who decides what a finding means
The report groups follow-up questions by who can answer them. Take legal questions to an attorney, financing questions to your lender and questions about the building to the relevant professional.
- The opinion of value
- The appraiser
- A reconsideration of value request
- The borrower, through the lender
- The loan
- The lender
- What the contract allows
- A Florida real estate attorney
What the report costs
Every report includes
- Analysis up to 500 pages
- Free repeat reviews when you add documents, up to the report’s limit
- A list of what Lysting reviewed, what was missing and which checks it could not complete
The rules behind the report
One request
One reconsideration request per appraisal, from the borrower through the lender
On a Fannie Mae or Freddie Mac loan, the borrower can make one reconsideration of value request for each appraisal report, through the lender, which sends it to the appraiser. Freddie Mac allows up to five alternative comparables with it. One request means the facts are best gathered before it goes.
Fannie Mae's answer is plain: "The borrower may request a maximum of one ROV for each appraisal report." The lender checks the request meets Fannie Mae's requirements before sending it to the appraiser.1 Freddie Mac's Guide permits "one Borrower-initiated ROV" per appraisal and a "maximum of five alternative comparables," each with the source of its data.2
A listing agent may not have the appraisal at all. Regulation B gives the copy to the loan applicant: the lender provides it "promptly upon completion, or three business days prior to consummation," whichever is earlier.3 The report is read from whatever copy the buyer shares.
Who may ask on each loan type, what a request holds and how it is decided are set out in the guide on how a reconsideration of value works.
The recorded facts
Facts an appraisal records that another record also states
Living area, bedroom and bathroom counts, lot size, features, and each comparable's sale date and price are recorded facts. Each can be set beside the county property record, a recorded deed or the listing sheet. Fannie Mae's independence rules let any party ask for factual errors in an appraisal report to be corrected.
The Appraiser Independence Requirements keep agents and other parties from pressing an appraiser on value, with one exception written into the text:
any party, including any Restricted Party, may request an Independent Party to provide additional information or explanation about the basis for a valuation, or to correct factual errors in an appraisal report.
An invented example: the appraisal against the county record
Appraisal, Improvementsp. 2
Gross living area: 1,180 sq ft
County property recordp. 1
Living area: 1,342 sq ft
What it leaves out
What the report leaves to the appraiser
Florida reserves to licensed appraisers any analysis, opinion or conclusion on the nature, quality, value or utility of a property, and counts an opinion about another appraiser's work as an appraisal review. The report states no value and no view of the appraiser's work. It sets the appraisal's facts beside other records.
any communication, written or oral, of an appraisal, appraisal review, appraisal consulting service, analysis, opinion, or conclusion relating to the nature, quality, value, or utility of a specified interest in, or aspect of, identified real property
So the report does not say an appraisal is wrong, and it does not choose comparables. It lists where the appraisal and another record state different facts, cites both, and leaves the agent or buyer to decide what goes into a request.
Sources
Every rule, date and limit above comes from one of these. The examples marked invented use invented figures. Where a rule is quoted, the wording is the source's.
- 1Reconsideration of Value (ROV), with frequently asked questionsFannie Mae, September 3, 2025
- 2Seller/Servicer Guide 5604.4, Reviewing appraisal reports, reconsideration of value requested by the BorrowerFreddie Mac, Effective September 3, 2025
- 3Regulation B, 12 CFR 1002.14, Rules on providing appraisals and other valuationsConsumer Financial Protection Bureau
- 4Appraiser Independence RequirementsFannie Mae
- 5Florida Statutes s. 475.611(1), definitions of appraisal report and appraisal reviewFlorida Legislature, 2026 Statutes
This page states what the published rules and forms say. It is not legal, lending, insurance, engineering or valuation advice, and it does not decide anything about a particular property.
Questions
Questions about the report
- Does the report say the appraisal is wrong?
- No. It sets the facts the appraisal records beside other records, cited to the page. Whether a figure changes is for the appraiser.
- Can a listing agent order it?
- Yes, with the appraisal the buyer shares. The copy goes to the loan applicant.
- Does it choose comparables?
- No. It reads the comparables you supply and sets their recorded facts beside the appraisal's.
- Which facts does the Appraisal check compare?
- The Appraisal check compares the living area, room counts and features the appraisal records with what the listing sheet and the county property record say about the same home. Where two records say different things, the report shows both passages with their pages, and the appraiser decides whether the appraisal changes.
- Is the Appraisal check an appraisal?
- The Appraisal check is not an appraisal: it states no value and no view of the appraiser's work. Section 475.611 of the Florida Statutes counts any communication of an analysis, opinion or conclusion on the nature, quality, value or utility of a property as an appraisal report, and section 475.612 lets only a certified or licensed appraiser issue one.
Appraisal check
$149 per report.